By Briony Penn, May 2016
With 18 large port expansion projects around the Salish Sea, how’s an ecosystem to survive the influx of tanker traffic?
SALT SPRING ISLAND is smack dab in the centre of the Salish Sea. On the clearest spring day, from our highest peaks, I can see the tip of Mount Waddington at the northernmost edge and Mount Rainier at the southernmost edge of the watershed. In between these two monarchs of mountains is a drainage basin of 110,000 square kilometres.
If I could swim among the hundreds of islands and the 18,000 square kilometres of water, I could catch a glimpse of over 100 different species of bird and 200 species of fish, 20 species of marine mammal and 3000 invertebrates—orcas to nudibranchs.
By Briony Penn, March 1, 2016
Reflections on the Great Bear Rainforest Agreement cannot leave out Chief Qwatsinas.
WITH AN ASSIGNMENT TO SUM UP the Great Bear Rainforest Agreement in 1500 words, I thought of Steinbeck’s quote. “It is advisable to look from the tide pool to the stars and then back to the tide pool again.” He was talking about the meaning of life but figuring out the Great Bear Rainforest Agreement is about as baffling and existential. The metaphor is also a good one to establish my limited credentials.
By Briony Penn, February 2016
How the National Energy Board found itself under attack by everyone in January.
JANUARY 2016 WAS full of news around Kinder Morgan’s Trans Mountain pipeline. As dozens of intervenors gave their final arguments in the closing days of the National Energy Board’s hearings, the federal government made moves towards living up to their pre-election promises.
By Briony Penn, January 2016
Most of New Zealand has been deforested due to agriculture, impacting biodiversity, water quality and the climate.
It is midnight and I am out with my brother in a rare patch of native manuka forest on New Zealand’s North Island. We’re shooting introduced possums that are eating the native birds and their forest habitat. On the next hillside over, young titi (sooty shearwaters, also known as muttonbirds) are settling into artificial burrows dug for them in their ancestral breeding grounds by members of the Maori iwi (the people or tribe), local ENGOs, and a team of scientists. We are all helping with a national campaign to give these birds a fighting chance to fledge from hills they haven’t occupied for over a century. Their burrows are behind a predator fence worthy of Fort Knox.
By Briony Penn, December 2015
BC Hydro accused of divide-and-conquer tactics among Peace River Valley First Nations.
BC Hydro’s press release, announcing the Site C dam startup, called it One Hundred Days of Construction. Opponents from First Nations, local landowners, and groups ranging from BC Union of Municipalities to Amnesty International have characterized it as “one hundred days of destruction.” And it is a level of destruction that opponents are arguing should never have taken place, especially before all the judicial reviews and appeals were finished.
The site where the clearing has started, at the southern confluence of the Peace and Moberly Rivers, was a mature forest which, like the rest of the 5340 hectares of valley to be flooded, has countless archaeological, sacred and historic sites, eagle nests, and wildlife corridors for moose, elk, bear and deer.
By Briony Penn, November 2015
The rise and fall of fish farming in Ahousaht territory.
Qaamina Hunter starts our telephone conversation by telling me I’ve reached the general store in Ahousat village. I apologize that I have called the wrong number (Is there a general store in Ahousat?). Then I hear him laugh. Judging by the children’s voices in the background, it might as well be a general store I’ve reached. Qaamina’s house is certainly some kind of major hub for this First Nation of 2000 people.
By Briony Penn, October 2015
The Unfair Election Act is coming soon—very soon—to a polling station near you.
In September 2, Chief Councillor of Tseshaht First Nations Hugh Braker QC made a phone call to his local Elections Canada office in Port Alberni. He was calling on behalf of the members of his community, many of whom are elders, new voters, or those without computers. He recorded the conversation and it went like this:
Office: Hello, Elections Canada
HB: Hi, I am the chief councillor for the Tseshaht First Nation. Do you have any printed material on how to register to vote that I could give to my members?
Office: We have posters here in our office. You can come in and write down what it says.
HB: No, I want to give it to the members and help them register. Can I get a poster from you for our office?
By Brioney Penn, September 2015
Owned by government pension plans, TimberWest appears set to ignore a Forest Practices Board finding about its logging on the island.
It’s taken six years, but just about everything with the Great Bear Rainforest (GBR) Agreement has been innovative. That includes new models for financing forest conservation; new ways of managing forests where the well-being of ecosystems and First Nations are the twin goals; new ways of resolving conflict where once-battling industry and environmental groups sit down committed to solutions; and finally, new ways to draft regulations through real BC-government-to-First-Nation-governments decision-making.
By Briony Penn, July/August 2015
Eight planned cutblocks in the Walbran are raising the temperature among those concerned about BC’s old-growth forests.
In 1991, Western Canada Wilderness Committee (WC2) campaigner, Torrance Coste, was a three-year-old growing up in Lake Cowichan. Barrelling through his community at the time were logging truck loads of old-growth logs coming out of the Walbran Valley and buses of protestors coming in. “I even remember the hand-painted signs: ‘No raw log exports’ which I could just about read.” Coste adds, “Though I didn’t have a clue what they meant then, I do now.”
By Briony Penn, June 2015
A sense of humour and humility are essential as settlers wade into the rich intertidal zone of decolonization.
The gathering of #1 seaweed, LEKES in the Coast Salish SENCOTEN language, is best done on a warm day in May when the tide is low and your heart is open to the possibility of wading into the intertidal zone of decolonization. It is a vital zone—messy and rich where land meets ocean, fresh water meets salt, settler meets indigenous, Western laws meet aboriginal title, and inundation follows dehydration every six hours. It is a zone in which you ask permission to enter, but are welcomed if you do.
By Briony Penn, May 2015
A scientific communicator takes on big oil and its so-called regulator.
When the Burrard oil spill started seeping onto English Bay beaches in April, the backstory of the oil industry’s corresponding rising share prices was already in the blogosphere. Kinder Morgan (Trans Mountain) owns half of Western Canada Marine Response Corporation (WCMRC), a company that has a monopoly on cleaning up spills on the coast. Lori Waters, a scientific communicator in rural Saanich, was connecting the dots for her blog followers in graphic detail.
By Briony Penn, March 2015
The federal government seems intent on propping up corporate fish farming despite the high costs.
On the afternoon of February 10, a whale watching boat docked at Port McNeill, packed to the limit with 48 Malcolm Islanders from the small village of Sointula.
They weren’t whale watchers; well, not the usual type. These were shrimp fishermen, fishing lodge operators, First Nations people, residents, members of local organizations, and biologist Alex Morton, who were coming to an open house of Grieg Seafood, the company that is proposing an expansion of two salmon farms in the Broughton Archipelago that would set a precedent of replacing shellfish tenures with finfish. The reason the islanders were delivered by a whale watching boat was because their ferry doesn’t run passengers on Tuesday afternoons; the meeting was scheduled at the time when it only carries dangerous cargo.
By Briony Penn, January 2015
Will adventure tourism and forest stewardship trump logging, pipelines and hunting in the Great Bear Rainforest?
The Canadian Embassy in Beijing recently opened its doors to the Chinese public to showcase Canada’s natural resources in big glossy photographs. Visitors shouldn’t expect pictures of oil rigs, LNG plants, mountains of coal or stacks of timber. Instead there are pictures of bears from the Great Bear Rainforest, orca in the Salish Sea, and sockeye salmon in the Adams River. The Chinese wildlife photographer Xi Zhinong, commissioned by the Canadian Tourism Association, told the China Daily, “Everyone yearns for magnificent nature and stunning animals. There are endless seas and forests in British Columbia. Various animals, including black bears, grizzly bears, whales, bald eagles and salmon can be found everywhere. In British Columbia, you can see the world as it first appeared.”
By Briony Penn, December 2014
A new documentary and public forum in Victoria in January will shed light on election fraud in Canada.
According to Peter Smoczynski, a 40-year veteran journalist and filmmaker from Ottawa, “Electoral fraud is a well organized crime. Millions of dollars are dedicated to duping various demographics of eligible voters in democratically run countries on election day.” Smoczynski, like many Canadians, believes something terribly wrong took place during the 2011 federal election.
The former CBC producer and documentary filmmaker is now half way through production of his new film Election Day in Canada: When Voter Suppression Comes Calling, due to be released before the 2015 election. Victorians will have a chance to preview clips and lend their voice and support to Smoczynski’s film at a forum sponsored by Focus Magazine and Open Cinema at the end of January.
By Briony Penn, December 2014
Who knew? There are 42 provincial parks, from the southern Gulf Islands to Port Renfrew, that need your help.
Colin Campbell arrives off the ferry for his interview sporting his new sky blue golfing shirt from Elgin, Scotland where he grew up and where he recently returned to play a few rounds and experience the Scottish referendum. This long time public servant looks like a great many of the boomers around Victoria, someone who is ready to spend the rest of his days pursuing a small white ball around golf links. But he is quick to dispel that notion.
By Briony Penn, October 2014
This summer’s marine life survey provides something to celebrate: resurgence.
On Bell Island off the northern tip of Vancouver Island this summer, I was restored to good health by, amongst other things, a wicked shot of vodka supplied by a passing group of Russians and Ukrainians wandering the coast on two small inflatable sailboats. They had an agreement amongst themselves not to discuss the war, while my own paddling companions—teachers—had an agreement to forget the strike for awhile. With the two dominant news items off the driftwood camp table, there was only our health and news of the coast to discuss around the vodka bottle at night.
By Briony Penn, September 2014
Evidence of destruction of old-growth forest on Sonora Island appears set to shake up BC’s South Central Coast forest policy.
Over my years of reporting on TimberWest, there has been virtually nothing that could bring the company’s inexorable liquidation of their forestlands to heel. Being named in a case before the Inter-America Commission for Human Rights, for example, hasn’t slowed the company down; nor has being the focus of a wide-spread media campaign by Greenpeace in 2011. Nor has being challenged by shareholders. Nothing seemed able to slow TimberWest’s relentless pace.
That is until two pairs of siblings, all born and raised in the shadow of the last of the old growth on the Discovery Islands, took to the woods of TFL 47 to investigate if TimberWest’s logging had transgressed rules protecting endangered old-growth ecosystems.
By Briony Penn, July/August 2014
This is just one of many projects being pushed forward without adequate consideration of costs and benefits.
In 1972, Justice Thomas Berger was appointed to conduct a federal government inquiry into a proposed oil and gas pipeline in the Mackenzie Valley. The Berger Inquiry set a new international standard for energy hearings that considered: the global energy context; the local impacts to aboriginal subsistence; and the impact of not just a pipeline but the expanded concept of an energy corridor, complete with roads, platforms and infrastructure. The ability to secure funding for First Nations and environmental groups captured the interest of the international community and was copied around the world.
By Briony Penn, June 2014
Is this threatened whale just too big a threat to Alberta’s oil-fuelled prosperity?
Just when humpback whales are starting to reestablish up and down the coast, including in the Salish Sea, the federal government is removing their legal protection. With the cynical Earth Day announcement of the delisting of the whale, many people are questioning how Prime Minister Stephen Harper managed to remove the obstacle to shipping bitumen from BC ports posed by a threatened whale in a threatened ocean. The downgrading of the official level of risk faced by BC’s humpback whale population cries out for an examination of how political interference is able to exert itself in the Byzantine process of designating species at risk, a process that is supposed to be non-political.
By Briony Penn, May 2014
Are the BC Liberals trying to take another step towards privatization of public forests?
On April 1, Forests, Lands and Natural Resource Operations Minister Steve Thomson announced that “A comprehensive public engagement process on converting some volume-based forest licences to new or expanded area-based tree farm licences will take place over the next two months.”
By Briony Penn, April 2014
Have the BC Liberals made it easier for pipelines to be built through provincial parks?
In March, the Park Act that once enshrined the protection of our parks, was pried apart by Christy Clark’s government with no public discussion. The amendment to the Act opens the door on pipelines, mining and industrial development in our parks. One voice alone was allowed to comment in the legislature: Opposition Critic for Tourism, Culture and the Arts Spencer Chandra Herbert was given five minutes. He argued at least for one simple, non-partisan amendment to the motion: “I hope, out of the goodness of mind and heart, the government will take the call from thousands upon thousands of British Columbians to put a pause, take a moment, and ask people what they think—to really be open, to really engage the people who pay our salaries, to give them the chance to have their say about their favourite areas.”
By Briony Penn, March 2014
International courts and BC teachers try to make up for government and corporate abuse of human and environmental rights.
The extraordinarily rich forests of Vancouver Island have been fought over since James Douglas had 14 Vancouver Island chiefs sign a blank piece of paper. The frustration in losing virtually every battle by four generations of First Nations and concerned citizens has bred some sophisticated new approaches to the old task of protecting Indigenous rights and nature. These reach out internationally and to corporate shareholders. As a result, 2014 is off to a difficult start for Island Timberlands, the corporation most in the news these days for questionable logging practices.
By Briony Penn, January 2014
By Briony Penn, December 2013
By Briony Penn, November 2013
Permits for development over First Nations’ burial grounds raise the question: Would the government ever say “no”?
In the heart of Victoria lies a peaceful sanctuary of century-and-a-half-old gravestones and trees called the Pioneer Square Cemetery, the “Old Burying Ground” for pioneer families. Currently underway are respectful repairs to its gravestones, paths and landscape. Meanwhile, Grace Islet, a tiny picturesque ancient Coast Salish burial site amongst ancient oaks and juniper, just off Salt Spring Island shores, lies desecrated by proposed residential development.
British Columbia’s Archaeology Branch, after a year of deliberation, chose Reconciliation Week to extend a provincial heritage site alteration permit to an Albertan businessman so he could build his luxury waterfront vacation home atop this First Nation cemetery.
By Briony Penn, October 2013
No moratorium on Discovery Islands logging
Last month Focus reported on Discovery Islands tourism operators’ frustration with the response from provincial ministers of tourism and forestry on three requests: that at least one of them come to the Discovery Islands and meet with the operators to see and hear their concerns first-hand; that a hold be put on the proposed viewshed logging in the three remaining unimpacted marine corridors until after the meeting; and that government strike a land-use committee of stakeholders to negotiate the demands of the different major economic interests.
By Briony Penn, September 2013
Government’s reluctance to limit logging in wilderness areas makes no sense when you do the math.
Somewhere around July of 2005, the tourism sector in British Columbia, for the first time in history, outstripped the forestry sector in GDP—in fact it outstripped all sectors including oil and gas—and hasn’t relinquished that position.
During the 10 years between 2001 and 2011, the GDP of forestry only increased 6 percent while tourism increased 23 percent. Vancouver Island and Vancouver Coast and Mountains regions attracted most (79 percent) of that tourism activity for BC, so the hot spot is right here on the coastal islands. In 2011, tourism on Vancouver Island increased 4 percent in just 12 months alone, beating all other industries hands down.
By Briony Penn, July/August 2013
A recent symposium of whale researchers examined the progress we’ve made in understanding these once-reviled creatures.
As a child in the 1930s my mother saw a rare pod of what she called “blackfish” from her rowboat in Haro Strait and was terrified. The conventional wisdom of colonial society then was that they were “killer” whales, rejected by the whalers for not being oily enough and shot indiscriminately as ruthless killers.
By 1955 there was still nothing that could dispel the aura of fear around these marine mammals. And fear unleashed brutality: A machine gun was mounted on Quadra Island near Ripple Rock, ready to shoot the killers as they passed by. Coincidently, that same year, Murray Newman, fresh from a doctorate in ichthyology at UBC’s zoology department, was hired as the first director of the Vancouver Aquarium, at the time hardly more than a series of fish tanks.
By Briony Penn, June 2013
Three Peace River residents talk about the changes they’re seeing as resource extraction ramps up.
“The feeling you get up here is that the Peace region is the sacrificial lamb for bailing out the economic troubles of the province. For many people, we are out of sight, so out of mind. But even people in industry up here are thinking: ‘this is getting crazy.’”
This is the message that local Peace River valley farmer Ken Boon wants people in the capital region to hear. Decisions about the Peace will be made in Victoria, yet many local residents and First Nations don’t sense that urban British Columbians are hearing their voices over the clamour of LNG boosters, political fear-mongering about job losses, and corporate ad campaigns.
By Briony Penn, May 2013
The Liberals have fumbled the biodiversity ball; so what are the alternatives offering, and what are they hedging on?
As mentioned in last month’s article, the BC Liberals have left a perfect vacuum for other political parties to fill on the biodiversity file. It’s been five years since government scientists warned that immediate action was necessary to avoid rapid deterioration of BC’s flora and fauna, especially in light of climate change.
During the last provincial election, the NDP’s axe-the-carbon tax policy cost them seats in tightly-contested ridings as environmentally-concerned voters migrated to the Greens. This time round, the wedge issue could be around the very stuff that sucks the carbon out of the atmosphere: BC’s biologically rich flora—and the fauna that digest it.
By Briony Penn, April 2013
What the auditor general and the scientists are saying.
Nature rarely makes it onto political platforms, but this election it could become a wedge issue amongst the progressive parties—especially in the capital. Here, if there is one thing that we rally around it’s the natural world. We gather in large crowds to save the salmon, the old growth or other iconic symbols of nature.
Yet the political parties are, as ever, reluctant to lead with the words “nature” or “biodiversity” in their platforms.
By Briony Penn, March 2013
BC Liberals go ahead with another giveaway of publicly-owned land to corporations.
Three years ago, in a feature report entitled “The Big Burn,” Focus revealed the findings of a dozen retired forest service professionals about BC Liberal plans to privatize BC’s forests under pressure from what are called “distressed asset managers.” These are the mega-corporations like BAM (Brookfield Asset Management; now the top performing company in Canada) and TAM (Third Avenue Management) that buy up majority interests in distressed logging companies (including Canfor, Weyerhauser, Catalyst, Western Forest Products, TimberWest, Island Timberlands etc).
By Briony Penn, February 2013
Climate policy experts are speaking out against various schemes to export more carbon from BC’s coastal ports.
Truck driver John Snyder retired to bucolic Fanny Bay to live the life, only to wake up one morning three years ago to find a notice on his doorstep—an invitation to an information session on the Raven Coal Mine, proposed five kilometres upstream of his home.
After attending the meeting, Snyder launched into his new career as a citizen researcher on the impacts of coal mining on his community. With others, he set up the group CoalWatch. As he says, “It started with concerns about how the mine might contaminate our wells, and took off from there.”
By Briony Penn, January 2013
Pension-owned companies may be liquidating our forests, but some communities are fighting back.
John Woolley, a retired public school teacher, recently blockaded a logging road with family and fellow islanders on Cortes Island to protect the 2,700-acre forest from an unlikely adversary—his own pension funds. Woolley is the latest kind of Vancouver Island activist: a pensioner appalled at the way his pension is being invested in the liquidation of private forest lands on Vancouver Island by companies in the portfolio of BC Investment Management Corporation (bcIMC). Says Woolley, “We are killing our own local economy and we are doing it to ourselves.”
By Briony Penn, December 2012
The Canadian Heavy Oil Association hopes a “factspill” will persuade British Columbians to support their pipelines.
Ian Anderson, CEO of Kinder Morgan, recently confessed at the annual fall business conference of the Canadian Heavy Oil Association in Calgary that “what I have come to understand is that consultation means something very different from handing out a bunch of baseball caps and nice dinners.” Dubbed by the Calgary Herald as a new breed of oilman with “hard-won wisdom,” Anderson admitted that those in the oil patch have misjudged and mischaracterized British Columbian’s opposition to their pipelines and tankers.
By Briony Penn, October 2012
The restorative powers of nature help immigrants as well as grandparents and their grandchildren.
There’s a different type of grandparent on the island these days—they play games, but it’s unlikely golf or bridge, and instead of Alaskan cruises with their peers, it will be a ferry ride to Galiano for an overnight camp.
These are the grandparents-raising-grandchildren and they are heading for the newly-established Galiano Restorative Learning Centre. According to Ken Millard, the driving force behind the Centre, providing a place to relax and play on beaches, lakes and in forests, prepare home-grown food, and sleep out under the stars with other families is one of the main goals of the new Centre as a project of the Galiano Conservancy Association.
By Briony Penn, September 2012
Victoria becomes a hub for re-connecting children to nature.
When the CBC asked Washington DC resident Roger Wood to describe the impacts that the summer’s freak storms, heat waves and electrical outages were having on his family, his response was not one that earlier generations could ever have anticipated. He replied that his three-year-old son Jordan “was bored.” Wood recounted how Jordan, cut off from television, internet and video games was miserable, revived only by the Cooling Centre where the Boys and Girls Club had set up a generator-run, air-conditioned computer room.
By Briony Penn, July/August 2012
The magic canoe is getting bigger as artists, journalists and others join the battle against oil tankers in coastal waters.
When local writer Arno Kopecky returned to Canada in 2011 after an assignment covering the Garcia regime in Peru, he had a bad case of déjà vu, or, as they say in Peru, yo visto. He had been documenting the impacts of mining, oil and timber extraction on the indigenous people during then-President Alan Garcia’s reign for his new book, The Devil’s Curve. Prime Minister Harper’s rhetoric on tar sands and pipelines was sounding awfully familiar. Says Kopecky, “I heard Garcia spouting all this stuff down in Peru about locals and foreign radicals standing in the way of progress. But then to come home to hear exactly the same thing coming out of our leaders’ mouths here…well I thought it only happened in banana republics.”
By Briony Penn, June 2012
How environmental protection in Canada went the way of the dodo.
Last month, my 16-year-old son’s class was flown to Ottawa, housed, fed, lectured to and trotted around the capital’s institutions and memorials devoted to war for a full week—courtesy of Stephen Harper’s government. According to David Pugliese, a veteran defense policy journalist, this youth indoctrination program is just a taste of what is to come.
And, as the defense “booster” budget explodes, the environmental budget implodes. It appears they are inextricably linked by the Harper agenda.
By Briony Penn, May 2012
The logging happens on private land, but the damage and costs are borne downstream.
In the last 10 years alone, Vancouver Island has had more severe flooding problems damaging homes, infrastructure and fish habitat than in the last 50. In the last five years, we’ve seen disaster-level flooding in central and southern Island (Dec 2007), Sooke and Langford (Jan 2009), Duncan (Nov 2009), central and north Island (Sept 2010, Dec 2010), and southeast Island (Nov 2011). Every year, sometimes twice a year, severe events are causing damages. The once exceptional has become the norm.
By Briony Penn, April 2012
Links between election fraud and oil interests are so thick, it appears bitumen itself is lubricating the connections.
OVER TWO DAYS in January, 2010, the Manning Centre for Building Democracy held a campaign school at Delta Ocean Pointe Resort in Victoria in preparation for the 2011 election. Revelations of what went on during those two days has yielded intriguing insight into what might lie behind the current robocall scandal. The Manning Centre is a Conservative think-tank operating out of Calgary, headed by Preston Manning, and board members include Gwyn Morgan, ex-CEO of EnCana Corp and other luminaries of the oil and gas industry.
By Briony Penn, March 2012
Author Wade Davis will be in Victoria March 7 to talk about efforts to save the Stikine, Skeena and Nass headwaters.
"This isn’t a souvenir coffee table book that the mining companies will take back home under their arms,” says Wade Davis about his new book, The Sacred Headwaters: The Fight to Save tbe Stikine, Skeena and Nass (Greystone, Oct. 2011).
By Briony Penn, February 2012
Stephen Harper’s government doesn’t want “socialist billionaires” messing with Canada’s resources unless they’re from China.
Why is the Canadian government behaving so bizarrely over the Enbridge Northern Gateway pipeline? That’s a hot topic as the pipeline hearings unfold. At the heart of the issue, many argue, is Canadian sovereignty over energy. As journalist and UVic lecturer Terry Glavin wrote in the National Post after the opening of the Enbridge hearings in old Kitimaat:
“If there were a global competition for the most brazen and preposterously transparent attempt by a ruling political party to change a necessary subject of national debate with alarmist distractions and hubbub, the Conservative escapade engineered in Ottawa these past few days really deserves some kind of grand prize.”
By Briony Penn, January 2012
The story of bees could possibly be the great allegory for our times.
It is a gorgeous Friday morning just outside of Bellingham. A flock of trumpeter swans are grazing in the fields, and I am with a large human flock hanging on every word of a hip young bee dude with a wicked sense of humour and two props—a collection of native bees and a bunch of sticks drilled with nest holes. The event is called Protecting Native Pollinators and there are farmers, students, scientists, teachers, grannies and young men jostling to learn the difference between a sweat bee and leafcutter bee; which native plants are best for bumblebees; and how to encourage mason bees (which mostly consists of doing nothing and being messy).
By Briony Penn, December 2011
A massive increase in the winter herring fishery threatens recovering stocks and resident orca.
In what many are calling a dangerous and reckless move, the Honourable James Ashfield, Minister of Fisheries and Oceans, has just opened a massively scaled-up winter herring fishery in the Salish Sea that could knock back all the recent small recoveries of local resident herring populations from Saanich Inlet and the Gorge to Ganges Harbour and Howe Sound.
By Briony Penn, November 2011
A First Nations case before an international court could spell trouble for the government pension funds that purchased TimberWest.
For the first time in Canadian history, an international human rights tribunal, the Inter-America Commission (IAC), will hear a human rights complaint against Canada, one brought forward by six southeast Vancouver Island First Nations of the Hul’qumi’num Treaty Group (HTG). With the failure of our provincial and national treaty process, First Nations are taking their cases to such international bodies to seek justice and, judging from comparable cases in the Americas, are likely to succeed.
All of us in the Capital region should be paying attention to this case as it could have broad and far-reaching implications—whether you are interested in human rights, urban sprawl, water quality, the future of our endangered forests…or your pension.
By Briony Penn, October 2011
Both the Fraser River sockeye and Pacific herring stocks are, by many accounts, on the verge of collapse, just as East Coast cod stocks did in the late 1980s. In the case of the cod, the Department of Fisheries and Oceans ignored early warnings from scientists and threatened some with loss of their jobs if they spoke out. Is that pattern repeating itself on the West Coast?
The unfolding presentations at the Cohen Commission Inquiry into the 2009 Fraser River sockeye collapse, as well as at a recent symposium on the collapse of the BC herring fishery, suggest that history may be repeating itself.
By the time the federal government imposed a moratorium on the eastern cod fishery in 1992, it was too late. Many questioned why the Department of Fisheries and Oceans (DFO) didn’t warn the government earlier.
By Briony Penn, September 2011
Two inquiries central to the health of coastal ecosystems are underway in Vancouver.
As Focus hits the street on August 30, schools of salmon researchers, fishers, First Nations, and advocates from all over British Columbia will be converging around the federal courthouse in Vancouver for the next stage of the Cohen Commission inquiry. They are coming to bear witness to the release of key evidence into the collapse of Fraser River sockeye stocks in 2009. This month, testimony shifts to the highly-charged topics of the role disease and aquaculture played in the deaths.
Concurrently, upriver at Simon Fraser University, an enquiry is being made into declining herring stocks—with another school of researchers, First Nations, fishers and herring advocates.
By Briony Penn, July 2011
China’s premier admits the massive Three Gorges Dam has created “urgent problems.” Is anybody at BC Hydro listening?
The premier of China, Wen Jiabo, recently made an official announcement that the Three Gorges dam, the world’s largest hydroelectric project, which has created a reservoir twice the length of Vancouver Island and displaced 1.3 million people, is experiencing “urgent problems.” Urgent on every front—dead water zones, pollution of drinking supplies, siltation, landslides, earthquakes, erosion, and drought. The project is also generating less power than it was designed for because of the danger of raising the reservoir to optimum levels; there’s been more displacement of residents, and massive destruction of the river ecosystems.
By Briony Penn, June 2011
A few thoughts on the lifeboats that pulled away from the wreck on May 2.
On the evening of May 2, along with the majority of Canadians, I was stunned. “Like winning bingo on the Titanic” was the saying that captured the mood of progressive islanders. Saanich–Gulf Islands had made history by electing the first Green Member of Parliament in Canada, while NDP undergrads fresh out of McGill were heading off to Ottawa as the official opposition. But as one of my friends remarked, it was a homeopathic remedy for a very serious illness—that of a Conservative majority.
Now that the dust has settled, I have come to realize that young Canadians have been handed an opportunity—one that is larger than the tar sands and more exciting than being in a crowd with a cellphone in Cairo. First, a little bit of background.
By Briony Penn, May 2011
Will the Nuu-chah-nulth Nation log the ancient forests of Flores Island?
Nuu-chah-nulth territory, the edge of the world where Captain Cook decided to anchor his boat and step ashore, is back in the news again—indeed it has hardly been out of the news over the last 200 years. It has a habit of making us reconsider how the West relates to aboriginal cultures and the rich natural environment that supports their commitment to self-sufficiency.
The deep sheltered sounds and forests on the west coast of the Island have been branded as bonanzas for two centuries. From fur traders to sealers, miners to missionaries, and loggers to fish farmers, they come from all over the world. They come to conquer but inevitably fail. They come to domesticate and the wild inevitably wins. The priests’ feral cows, Cougar Annie’s dahlias, and the Norwegians’ Atlantic salmon don’t linger long.
By Briony Penn, April 2011
How much does your daily dose of water weigh?
Imagine walking from Royal Oak into downtown Victoria to fill up a large plastic container with water and then walking home with the 20-kilogram load supported by a narrow head strap. Then imagine that you have to do it every other day while feeling weak, sick and hungry, and with children to mind along the way. Add in the fact that a prolonged drought has left the rivers low and harbouring disease and hungry crocodiles, and you’ll understand the plight of the Masaai women of Oleleshua, Kenya.
By Briony Penn, March 2011
With feds like these, who needs enemies?
Southern resident orcas are set to swim back into Canadian and US courts this spring with the hopes of jumping two major legal hoops that could finally protect the marinescape for these endangered species.
The Canadian courts are reconvening after the federal fisheries minister launched an appeal against Justice James Russell’s historic ruling in December 2010. That ruling said it was unlawful for the minister to exercise discretionary powers regarding the protection of critical habitat under the Species At Risk Act (SARA).
by Briony Penn, January 2011
First Nations lead the fight against Enbridge’s $5.5 billion Northern Gateway Project.
On December 7, all opposition parties in the House of Commons united to pass a motion requesting an immediate legislative ban on oil tanker traffic in Dixon Entrance, Hecate Strait and Queen Charlotte Sound. On December 14, a bill providing that legislation was tabled in the House of Commons.
By Briony Penn, January 2011
The vicissitudes of life in the intertidal zone mirror that of today’s middle class.
A new term has been coined to describe the disintegrating middle class of the western world—the precariat—who live a precarious and frantic existence of juggling jobs, families, mortgages and civic duties within a crumbling social and environmental net.
The British economist Guy Standing, who coined the term, suggests that half the British population—shortly to swell ever larger as another 300,000 civil servants are dismissed by the Cameron regime—would describe themselves as members of this class.
By Briony Penn, December 2010
Offsets could be used to save nature—but a lot can go wrong.
I am a carbon cowgirl. For the last three years, I’ve been riding the range on my pony Green Gold, trying to find out if carbon offsets can help us buy both time and threatened natural ecosystems (which function as carbon sinks) in the climate-change countdown.
If ever there was a wild-west frontier, the carbon markets are it, with cowboys from Texas to Hamburg lassoing carbon deals.
by Briony Penn, November 2010
Delicious revenge or deep forgiveness? We have apt role models for each.
There are two good women on my mind this month: Lisbeth Salander, the girl who played with fire and Helen Stewart, the woman who aches for beauty. They have nothing in common. Yet, they have everything in common. Both are sick of the relentless exploitation of the vulnerable.
One is a fictitious Pippy-Longstocking-turned-punk-hacker who takes out the bullies with cunning and force in a gritty crime novel set in urban Sweden. The other is a real mother-artist-turned-naturalist-writer who endures great loss and destruction by calling on the restorative quality of nature and art in a children’s book set in the forests of BC.
by Briony Penn, October 2010
Heroes of coastal ecosystem protection are not extinct… yet.
Last month, I wrote about unreported crimes against the natural world, and got feedback that the next column should be on the unreported heroes trying to prevent those unreported crimes.
Some of you will have come across Laura Matthias before. She’s a Balkan Babe—one of the talented, young, all-female singing group that won a prestigious place in the national showcase of top Canadian singing ensembles this time last year. She’s also the author of ExtraVeganZa—a best-selling vegan cookbook that makes eating vegan a culinary adventure, not an ethical ordeal.
by Briony Penn, September 2010
The birds and the bees are missing in action and so, as Stockwell Day says, what we need are more prisons.
I couldn’t agree more with Stockwell Day that there is a rise in “unreported crimes.” I have been keeping a tally this summer of crimes against our life systems that no one reports. The interesting thing about such unreported crimes is that not only is the activity itself a crime, but the lack of reporting is one too. And both are escalating precipitously.
I have absolutely no data to prove the degree of assault on ecosystems. All I have are my eyes and intuition, because the federal scientists who normally gather statistical data on population declines and environmental impacts and threats have either been let go, muzzled or resigned in passionate frustration.
As for evidence of lack of reporting, I only have the absence of data to go on.
By Briony Penn, August 2010
The combination of a gutted Forest Service, vast areas of not sufficiently restocked forestlands, a quirky loophole in the Kyoto Protocol and a provincial government ideologically driven to sell off public assets has created the perfect opportunity for forest industrialists to burn down the last barriers to privatization of BC’s Crown forests.
On August 20, 1910, a strong wind blew down off the Cascades and whipped hundreds of forest blazes into an inferno that extinguished towns and three million hectares of forests from Washington to Montana.
By Briony Penn, July 2010
Caribou and conservation need to be part of the conversation around the Site C dam.
It’s 2005. Award-winning aboriginal musician/TV host and researcher Art Napoleon is standing on top of the WAC Bennett dam. I’ve joined him in Peace country to work on a documentary film proposal. Called Disturbing the Peace, it will raise awareness about the potential impacts of the proposed Site C dam on the Peace and the other energy projects that riddle the northeast corner of BC.